Who were James Gang?
The James Gang formed in Cleveland, Ohio, in 1966 and quickly became one of America’s premier hard rock acts. The classic lineup of Joe Walsh, Dale Peters, and Jim Fox earned a reputation for powerful live performances and inventive songwriting. Albums such as James Gang Rides Again and Thirds established the group as a major force in early-1970s rock. However, when Walsh left in late 1971 to pursue a solo career—eventually joining the Eagles—the future of the band seemed uncertain. Rather than disband, bassist Dale Peters and drummer Jim Fox recruited Canadian musicians Roy Kenner and Domenic Troiano, formerly of the band Bush, effectively creating a revitalized version of the James Gang.
Straight Shooter – The Album Review
Straight Shooter was the first album recorded by this new lineup. The record was cut in early 1972 at Quadrafonic Sound Studios in Nashville and was produced collectively by the band members themselves. The sessions reflected a group determined to establish its own identity rather than live in the shadow of its former star. Troiano brought a more melodic and sophisticated guitar style, while Kenner’s soulful vocals added a fresh dimension to the band’s sound. The result was an album that blended hard rock, blues influences, and melodic songwriting into a cohesive and engaging whole.
One of the album’s standout tracks is “Kick Back Man.” Built around a driving groove and an infectious chorus, the song perfectly showcases the chemistry between Troiano’s guitar work and Kenner’s energetic vocals. It has the confidence of a band eager to prove itself and remains one of the strongest performances on the record. Equally impressive is “Get Her Back Again,” a concise rocker featuring sharp guitar lines and memorable hooks. Troiano’s playing throughout the song is tasteful and expressive, demonstrating why he was considered one of the most respected guitarists on the Canadian rock scene.
Another highlight is “Getting Old,” a thoughtful and mature composition that reveals the band’s growing musical sophistication. The song combines introspective lyrics with a rich arrangement, creating one of the album’s most emotionally resonant moments. “Let Me Come Home” continues this trend, balancing heartfelt songwriting with powerful instrumentation. Its expansive structure allows the musicians room to stretch out while maintaining a strong melodic focus.
The album closes with “My Door Is Open,” perhaps its most ambitious track. Running nearly six minutes, it combines soulful vocals, dynamic shifts, and excellent ensemble playing. The performance highlights the strengths of the new lineup and leaves the listener with the sense that the James Gang had successfully entered a new chapter rather than merely surviving the loss of a key member.
What makes Straight Shooter particularly rewarding is its willingness to evolve. Instead of chasing the heavier power-trio sound that brought the band earlier success, the album explores broader musical territory. Kenner’s vocal style introduces warmth and soul, while Troiano’s guitar approach favors texture and melody over flash. The rhythm section of Peters and Fox remains as solid as ever, providing the foundation that allows the newer members to flourish. Together, they create an album that feels confident, adventurous, and remarkably cohesive.
Although Straight Shooter did not achieve the commercial success of the band’s Joe Walsh-era releases, it remains an important chapter in the James Gang story. The album reached the Billboard 200 and demonstrated that the group still had artistic vitality despite significant lineup changes. It also paved the way for later incarnations of the band before their eventual breakup in 1977, though reunions over the years have reminded fans of the group’s enduring legacy.
The Vinyl Review
I’m not sure exactly how much I parted with in order to purchase this excellent album but I doubt it was more than a fiver. The sleeve is in great shape apart from a bit of fluffing on the top which would have naturally occurred over time. After a quick clean the vinyl plays beautifully and crackles with all the intensity you would want from an album older than good myself!!! However, what isn’t so good is my memory as I cannot recall where and when I picked it up!!
Donnie’s Rating: 8.5/10
